
Both types of cover are there for a time when illness stops you earning. They pay out in different ways and for different events, so they are not alternatives so much as two answers to two questions.
Critical illness cover
Pays a single tax free lump sum if you are diagnosed with one of the conditions listed in the policy, and the diagnosis meets the policy's definition. Cancer, heart attack and stroke are the best known. Policies differ in how many conditions they cover and how each is defined.
Useful for: clearing or reducing the mortgage, paying for changes to your home, or giving your family time without money worries.
Limits: it pays only for the listed conditions. Many reasons people are off work, such as back problems or stress, are not usually covered.
Income protection
Pays a monthly income if you cannot work because of illness or injury, whatever the cause. It usually covers a share of your earnings, often between half and two thirds. Payments start after a waiting period you choose, and continue until you return to work, the policy ends or you retire, depending on the terms.
Useful for: paying the mortgage and bills month after month during a long absence.
Limits: it does not pay a lump sum, and it pays only while you are unable to work.
Check your sick pay first
Before choosing, find out what your employer pays. Many NHS staff have sick pay that reduces over time and depends on length of service. Other employers pay statutory sick pay only. If you are self-employed, you have no employer cover. The waiting period on income protection can be set to match the point where your sick pay runs out, which keeps the cost down.
Do you need both?
They do different jobs, and many households hold some of each. If the budget allows only one, think about which would hurt more: a long time without income, or a serious diagnosis with a mortgage still to pay.
What affects the price
Your age, health, smoking status, occupation, the amount of cover and, for income protection, the waiting period and how long it will pay.
Read the definitions, not only the list of conditions. Two policies can cover the same illness on very different terms.
How we help
We compare policies across a range of insurers and explain the differences in plain English. See our pages on critical illness cover and income protection.
Common questions
Is life insurance the same as critical illness cover?
No. Life insurance pays on death. Critical illness cover pays on diagnosis of a listed condition. They are often bought together.
Will a health condition I already have be covered?
It depends on the condition and the insurer. It may be excluded, covered at a higher price, or covered as normal.